Home » Tools » Top 10 Best Screw Extractors On The Market 2020 Reviews

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

Top 10 Best Screw Extractors On The Market 2020 Reviews

No one likes getting screws stuck in the wood. Whether it’s a stripped screw or an old one tat’s jam-packed into the surface, a screw extractor can always come in handy. Screw extractors work in two ways: they drill a hole in the stripped/jammed screw. Then they gently drill the screw out due to their reverse threading.

Screw extractors have various applications, ranging from your kitchen to your garage. But which extractors are the best for use with automotive parts? And which ones are worth your time and money?

Well, we’re here to find out. Below we have reviewed our top 10 choices for the bets screw extractors.

So let’s dive into our top 10 picks!

Best Screw Extractors

Best Screw Extractor Comparison Table

NameBox WeightNo. of PiecesMaterialStyleRating

Box Weight
5.4 lbs
No. of Pieces
48
Material
Cobalt
Style
Drill bits and extractors
4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)

Box Weight
0.9 lbs
No. of Pieces
5
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Extractors
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Box Weight
4 lbs
No. of Pieces
25
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Extractors
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Box Weight
0.25 lbs
No. of Pieces
4
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Drill bits and extractors
4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)

Box Weight
0.25 lbs
No. of Pieces
1
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Screw extracting pliers
4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)

Box Weight
1.62 lbs
No. of Pieces
8
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Extractors
4 out of 5 stars (4 / 5)

Box Weight
0.19 lbs
No. of Pieces
4
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Drill bits and extractors
3.6 out of 5 stars (3.6 / 5)

Box Weight
0.7 lbs
No. of Pieces
10
Material
Cobalt
Style
Drill bits and extractors
3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)

Box Weight
0.2 lbs
No. of Pieces
4
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Drill bits and extractors
3.8 out of 5 stars (3.8 / 5)

Box Weight
0.2 lbs
No. of Pieces
6
Material
Carbon steel
Style
Extractors
3.3 out of 5 stars (3.3 / 5)

Top 10 Best Screw Extractors For The Money 2020 Reviews

1 Irwin Drill Bit Set/Screw Extractor

Say goodbye to rusty bolts and screws that just won’t budge. IRWIN’s extractor drill is designed to pull out fasteners even if they’ve completely rusted with time.

What does it feature?

This set features 48 pieces, including bolt extractors, spiral flute extractors, and even multi-spline extractors. Combined with the stunning deep blue toolbox, this IRWIN set is a complete collection of screw extractor drill bits.

Here’s more…

This screw extractor drill bit set has a spiral design that digs deep into screws that won’t budge. The spiraling head creates an intense amount of torque. The flutes dig deeper as you turn the drill, and even rusty screws can be easily pulled off.

That’s not all…

The IWRIN Drill Bits are 100% compact and low-profile. Which means You can use them on smaller screws. The compact design also helps create maximal torque, perfect for smaller screws.

What’s more…

IRWIN’s screw extractor drill bits are highly versatile. You can use them with any and all types of screws and bolts. This includes bolts and screws that have been painted over or have become victim to dust, grease, and rust. Moreover, stripped bolts can also be gripped easily by the IWRIN drill bits.

Last but not least…

The IRWIN drill bits also have bolt extractors that work to free slightly exposed fasteners. Moreover, the set also includes left-hand drill bits coated with cobalt to free the interior of screws and bolts. This makes releasing the fastener a whole lot easier and quicker.

Irwin Drill Bit Set/Screw Extractor
Our rating:4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)

Pros

  • Works on a variety of fasteners.
  • Effortless to use even on the smallest screws and bolts.
  • Has everything you need to get started.
  • Perfect for use by professional repairmen.
  • It can be used on fasteners of varying sizes.

Cons

  • You need to press hard to create a hole on the fastener.

2 Irwin Bolt Extractor

Here’s yet another bolt extractor set from IRWIN. This set contains 5 pieces of premium quality bolt extractors. IRWIN’s extractors have always been the most versatile and diverse bunch.

To top all the other features, these extractors come in a lavish royal blue toolbox with bold yellow lettering.

To start off…

Each bolt extractor has been designed with reverse spiral flutes. This allows the bits to “bite down” on the bolts and create maximal torque.

What does this mean?

This means that even rusted, painted over, and highly tightened bolts can be easily unfastened. To add to that, each bolt has been welded from high carbon steel.

For those of you who don’t know, this type of steel is highly durable, withstanding a ton of pressure and heat. This not only means that you can use your drill bits with a drill press but also ensures the longevity of the product.

To set these bolt extractors aside from the others, IRWIN has used a universal lobular architecture. This makes the extractors fit bolts of all shapes. However, the size range is limited.

Here’s more…

This set is only compatible with bolts of sizes 11, 14, and 16 mm. It can also be used on bolts of sizes 3/8”, up to half an inch. The size range accounts for both larger bolts and the smaller compact ones.

This IRWIN set is recommended for use by automotive repairmen. It’s the perfect set for removing bolts on internal car parts and engines. It’s also a great choice for garage repair jobs, as the set only contains 5 extractors.

Irwin Bolt Extractor
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Extracts bolts of various sizes, even the smaller ones.
  • You can use it with a drill press.
  • Designed for bolts of all shapes.
  • Easy-to-carry toolbox with a lock.
  • Removes bolts that are rounded-off and rusted.

Cons

  • The set does not contain all the tools.

3 Irwin Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw Extractor

This 25-piece screw extractor set from IRWIN is the perfect companion for everyday garage repairs. Nested in the signature blue toolbox, these IRWIN tools are the best screw extractors on the market.

Like the other IRWIN tools, this set also contains extractors with spiral flutes. The flutes help the drill to dig deep into the screw’s head and pull it out. The spiraling flutes create a torque that forces the screw out, even if it’s jammed.

What’s more?

The spiral design used on these extractors is left-handed, as is standard. Left-hand spiraling is generally preferred to maximize the rotating power and aggressiveness.

The set contains 25 extractor heads of varying sizes, all of the same shape (hexagonal). The size of the extractors varies from 1/8” to up to 7/8”.

Confused as to which head to use for which screw? Don’t worry.

This IRWIN toolbox features markings on the extractors that read out the size of the extract.

The manufacturers have also etched the recommended size of the drill bit onto the side of each extractor. So you know exactly what to do with your extractor of choice.

But here’s a catch…

These extractors are only compatible with hex-head screws. Hex-head screws have six sides and are the most common types of screws.

Irwin Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw Extractor
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Works with screws of multiple sizes.
  • All extractors come in a well-organized toolbox.
  • Longer lifespan and lifetime guarantee.
  • Extracts can be used on highly compact screws as well.
  • Highly user-friendly with a user-oriented design.

Cons

  • When you shake the toolbox, the pieces fall out and may get shuffled.

4 Alden Grabit Pro Screw Extractor

If you don’t own a professional car repair store and just want a small kit for your garage, then this is it. The Alden Grabit 8440P contains only 4 extractor drill bits. The limited number of extractors makes this the perfect household tool kit.

Each of the drill bits is dual-ended and you can use them for extracting jammed, rusted, and painted-on screws.

Here’s more…

The drill bits have two ends: the burnishing end and the threaded end. The burnishing tip helps to “prepare” the screw for extraction. Use this to allow for a smooth extraction.

Use the threaded tip to grab the screw and extract it with ease. This two-step process is neither too comprehensive nor too tiring.

Is that all? No, wait!

Each drill bit has been designed to work with screws of different sizes. For example, drill bit number 1 deals with No.4 to No.7 screws. It also deals with No.10 bolts, which usually measure 5 mm. Bit Number 2 is perfect for use with screws of No.8 to No.10.

What’s more?

It can also be applied to extract 6 mm bolts. The 3rd bit is to be used with No.11 to No. 14 screws and 8 mm bolts. While the 4th bit can handle screws between No.16 and No.24, as well as 10 mm bolts.

Lastly,

This high versatility and size range capabilities remove all necessity for additional extractors. These 4 extractors are perfect for use in your garages and tool shacks. Extractors of bigger diameters are not included, but they are usually used in heavy auto repair jobs.

Alden Grabit Pro Screw Extractor
Our rating:4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)

Pros

  • Drill bits cover a wide range of screw and bolt sizes.
  • This is the perfect companion for everyday automotive repair.
  • Compact toolbox with only the bits that you need.
  • Produces a powerful turning motion.
  • Prepares the screws before unfastening.

Cons

  • Too aggressive. May break weak screws in two.

5 Vampire Tools International Vampliers Portable

If the typical drill bit extractors aren’t your cup of tea, then the Vampliers might pique your interests. These pliers aren’t like ordinary pliers, they are specially designed for screw and bolt extraction.

But that’s not all…

These pliers have a unique concave-shaped head with both vertical and horizontal threading on the inside.

The jaws are highly powerful and clasp onto screws and bolts. The handles provide torque and keep the motion relatively aggressive and powerful. However, what’s best about the Vampliers is that they don’t damage weak screws and bolts.

Ideally, it would be best to replace weak screws entirely. But the force of the Vampliers is sufficient enough to keep screws intact.

What’s the best part?

These pliers handle all types of screw heads. Since they don’t have a molded tip, they can adapt to any and all screw shapes. So whether you have a hex head, Torx head, single-sided, or even a security screw, the Vampliers got your back.

These pliers are made from the highest grade carbon steel made in Kobe in Japan. Carbon steel is a common element in heavy machinery as it’s highly malleable and resistive to pressure.

So you can use the Vmapliers for just about any task, and they won’t even so much as accumulate a scratch. The only downside is the size limitation. The Vampliers cannot be used on larger screws or bolts. This makes it perfect for regular everyday use. But for heavier automotive repair, it may not be 100% sufficient.

Vampire Tools International Vampliers Portable
Our rating:4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)

Pros

  • Highly versatile. Works with screws of all shapes.
  • It can turn without damaging the screws or the surface.
  • It does not accumulate scratches or abrasions.
  • A great companion for everyday garage use and small-scale repair.
  • 100% authentic product with a lifetime guarantee.

Cons

  • It cannot be used for bigger bolts or for heavier automobiles.

6 Nizzco Screw Extractor Set

Back to the traditional drill bit extractors, here’s another one that might interest you. This screw and bolt extractor set from Nizzco comes in a professional heavy-duty case and holds up to 8 drill bits.

Each drill bit has a long threaded tip that digs deep into the screw or bolt and spins it out. We especially chose this set as it’s both ideals for personal as well as commercial use.

Here’s more…

The set contains 8 drill bits made from the finest carbon steel. This steel has been tempered twice to increase its resilience and to enhance tensile strength. With the dual-tempered steel, these bits are able to withstand brute force from drills and drill presses.

What makes these bits work?

The threading on these is left-hand oriented. Normally, screws have a right-hand thread orientation. So the opposing thread handedness pulls the screw out with ease.

What’s the best in these?

This 8 piece screw extractor set can be used on water pipes too. So you can even use them to handle plumbing jobs. And the versatility doesn’t end there. This 8-piece set can be used for screws ranging from 1/8” to 1”.

This is by far the largest screw size range we have seen. And it accounts for some high functionality.

Nizzco Screw Extractor Set
Our rating:4 out of 5 stars (4 / 5)

Pros

  • Reliable and qualitative extractor heads with high silence.
  • It can withstand pressure from drills and high power motors.
  • Long threaded head digs deep into the bolts, screws, and fasteners.
  • You can use if on a wide range of bolt and screw sizes.
  • Easy to carry and move about in the silver tool case.

Cons

  • May require elbow grease to work properly.

7 Speedout Screw And Bolt Extractor

Speed Out’s damaged screw extractor set is perhaps the most versatile and diverse extractor kit. This kit features only 4 screw extractor bits, but these are sufficient for handling most screws and bolts.

Packed in a matte black case that keeps the bits secure, the SpeedOut is your one-stop for garage auto repair.

Here’s more…

This set features extractor drill bits made from reinforced carbon steel. Carbon steel is not only resilient, withstanding high pressure and heat. But it can also survive the sands of time. So your SpeedOut set will last you decades to come.

The set doesn’t get scratched or abraded by household chemicals, grease, or by drill pressure. Moreover, you can use the SpeedOut drill bits in extremely cold conditions as well without worrying about the bits jamming.

The best part…

These screw extractors work on both wood and machine screws. So they are best for heavy-duty work. Moreover, they can be used on hex-head, flat, and Philips screws. So there’s tons of variety. Plus, the four sizes are perfect for large and small screws.

Each drill bit has two sides. One side is to prep the screw. Pulling the screw out initially is the hardest task. The heavier end of the drill bit is designed to pull out the screw from the jammed surface.

Next, flip the drill bit around to smoothly extract the screw or bolt from the surface. You can’t use the prep side for the final extracting as it’s too powerful and may break the screw or damage the surface.

Speedout Screw And Bolt Extractor
Our rating:3.6 out of 5 stars (3.6 / 5)

Pros

  • Works in two steps.
  • Easy to use and understand.
  • Four drill bits come in a case
  • They don’t shuffle when shook.
  • Works on most types of screws and bolts.
  • Concise set.
  • Heat and pressure-resistant.

Cons

  • You cannot use it to extract special screws like Torx head.

8 Neiko Screw Extractor

Neiko is a brand that has stood for quality and reliance. This 10 piece screw extractor set is all you need in your home, work, and repair shack. These screw extractors feature spiral flutes with a multi-spline design and a highly durable body.

And to add to all that….

They come in a unique tool case design that optimizes the size of your drill bits.

First things first, let’s talk about durability.

This drill bit set consists of extractors made from the finest cobalt. This cobalt has been reinforced with high-grade steel to extend the service life of the equipment.

Durability for cobalt extractors is very crucial, as these fragile bits need to withstand load from the drill. More importantly, they need to be aggressive enough to pull the screw out.

The way these extractors work is that you find the correct size of the extractor. Then you attach it onto the end of your drill. Drill into the screw, then gently pull it out.

Remember to not pull it out with too much aggression or the screw can break. The set includes sizes 5/64” to 19/64” allow steel extractors. The set also includes corresponding sizes of left-hand drill bits, which can be used for various purposes.

Moreover, the red toolbox has been designed to provide an optimal organization. It even features a lock to keep your precious bits from being stolen, lost, or mishandled by children.

Neiko Screw Extractor
Our rating:3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Includes both extractors and left-hand bits.
  • Grips the screw firmly, leaving no room for accidents.
  • An easy organization with the red toolbox.
  • Survives stress and heat.
  • Suitable for use in professional auto repair shops and garages.

Cons

  • Cannot handle heavier bolts.

9 Easyout Screw Extractor

No other drill bit set has cut it for you? Then this product may just be the one. Behold the EasyOut set-of-4 drill bit case. This set contains everything you need for a simple car repair job or plumbing replacement. These screw extractors are highly powerful and can be used on all types of screws and bolts.

Now, let’s talk about versatility.

These screw extractors can work with any type of drill. And they can handle all types of screws and bolts, ranging from 3 to 12 mm. This means that they can be used for bigger and heavier screws as well.

And the drill bits won’t even break under the heavy pressure of the drill. They work by generating torque and rotating the screw anticlockwise to release it from the surface.

What’s the real story?

This screw extractor set can remove even the most stubborn bolts and screws. Even if the screw is rusted, embedded, jammed, or painted over. Like most others, you need to follow two simple steps in order to get the job done.

First, use the screw remover head to drill a hole into the top of the screw. Then dig the extractor side into the hole and gently pull out the screw.

The material used to forge these extractors has a hardness rating of 63 to 65 HRC. The higher the hardness rating, the better the material will perform.

Last but not least…

This is a set of 4 screw extractors and drill bits that can be used with many different types of screws. This includes Torx and Phillips head screws, as well as flat heads and numerous bolts.

Easyout Screw Extractor
Our rating:3.8 out of 5 stars (3.8 / 5)

Pros

  • Excellent design for pulling and rotating the screw out.
  • 4 drill bits are suitable for small garage repairs and plumbing jobs.
  • Highly durable with heavy reinforcements.
  • You can use it on multiple screw heads and bolts.
  • Highly powerful.
  • Withstand pressure and temperature.

Cons

  • The toolbox is weak.

10 Ampro Screw Extractor

If all else didn’t work for you, then here’s one last entry before we finish the reviews off. The AMPRO Set of 6 Screw Extractors may be last on our list, but definitely not last on our priorities. This screw extractor is an excellent choice for people looking for an affordable drill extension.

The reason why it’s last on our list is that the quality isn’t all that reliable. And the extractors don’t come in a toolbox either.

Moreover, these screw extractor bits are the best choice for anyone with a small garage. They have extra-long threaded heads that dig deep into your screw and pull the damaged fastener out. This set contains six screw extractors of SAE sizes.

What’s the best part?

The sizes range from 1/8 inches to up to ¾ inches. This means you can use it for screws of medium to small sizes. However, for larger, heavier screws and bolts, we wouldn’t recommend this product.

Also, the extractors aren’t fit for professional use as they lack the type of durability needed. They are made from alloyed steel but are unable to budge when dealing with bigger screws.

However, what makes this screw extractor set so unique is that it works with multiple types of screw heads. You can use it for Phillips, slotted, Robertson, Allen, and even Torx screws.

Last but not least…

We highly recommend this screw extractor set for personal use, especially in home garages and repair jobs. You can use them for fixing automotive parts, sprinklers, fire hydrants, and even plumbing systems.

Ampro Screw Extractor
Our rating:3.3 out of 5 stars (3.3 / 5)

Pros

  • Highly versatile.
  • You can use it in various everyday repair jobs.
  • Perfect for use in the garage, kitchen, yard, and bathroom.
  • Drills through most types of screw heads.
  • Multi-fluted design helps the drill dig deeper.

Cons

  • You cannot use it for heavier and tighter screws and bolts.

Best Screw Extractor Buying Guide

Quality

The sign of a high-quality screw extractor is that it will not deteriorate for over a decade. The higher-end screw extractors usually last for about 12 to 13 years.

If you feel that a particular screw extractor is too loaded with features for it to last more than a few years, then it will not be worth it.

It might cost much more than the normal kind of screw extractor but it will definitely last longer which will automatically save you more money.

Convenience

When looking for screw extractors, you must make sure to pick out the ones that are ergonomic. This means that you have to look for the ones that give you added convenience. The screw extractors that come with handy features that make your life easier are the ones you should go for.

When picking out a screw extractor, make sure to hold it in your hand and check the grip. See how it fits between your fingers and if it feels comfortable. You would not want to work with a tool that makes your fingers ache.

Materials

The construction of the screw extractor is of equal importance when you’re considering to buy one. Some of the best and high-quality screw extractors offer a cobalt body.

These are much more affordable than the carbon-fiber variants. However, if you can afford to spend a bit more coin on the tool, you should definitely go for the carbon-fiber variant.

Make sure the manufacturer has not used aluminum or any other kind of “soft” metal. They will not last that long and they will make working the tool a nightmare.

Compatibility

It is of vital importance that your screw extractors should be compatible with the kind of screws you want to work with. Before buying a screw extractor, you should compare the supported screws and screw sizes with the kind you are wishing to use on. It would be a disaster if you picked out the wrong one.

Size Of The Screws

There are some screw extractors that allow you to easily use them on any kind of screw or problem. However, there are certain screw extractors that are built to handle a certain size of screws.

You should manually check each and every tool in the line to see if the screw extractor will fit your needs or not.

Warranty

A simple rule of thumb to follow when buying screw extractors is that if they do not come with extended warranties then they are not good for you.

A high-quality screw extractor should come with an extended warranty. This means that the manufacturer has faith in their product and that they are willing to repair any damage.

Wrap Up

A screw gone bad is never the most pleasing find. But it shouldn’t have to stay for long. Our top 10 screw extractors work wonders in removing screws from their surfaces. So whether your screw breaks or gets jammed, you can confide in our top picks.

But remember, the real choice is in your hands. Choose the extractor set that suits you the best. No extractor on our list was a disappointment, at least for us. So make the best decision for yourself and get yourself a screw extractor set today!

Leave a Comment