Home » Top 5 Best Soft Car Top Carriers Of 2021 Detailed Reviews

When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

Top 5 Best Soft Car Top Carriers Of 2021 Detailed Reviews

One of the best and most efficient ways to increase storage space in the car is a soft top carrier. These carriers are like bags held on the roof of your car and can safely carry your luggage from place to place. Soft carriers are easier to install than hard carriers and weigh considerably less as well.

No one dislikes extra storage space. More storage has, in fact, become a growing need for the majority.

For this reason, in this article, we will review some of the best soft car top carriers for our readers to get help from.

Top 5 Best Soft Car Top Carriers Of 2021 Detailed Reviews

Best Soft Car Top Carriers Comparison Table

There are plenty of options available out there for soft car top carriers. They have varying features that give them the edge over one another in specific situations. However, all of them securely carry the luggage. Let’s take a look at our top five picks.

ProductsStorage spaceMounting hardware requirementLock includedRating
Storage space
15 cubic feet
Mounting hardware requirement
Two or four sided racks.
Lock included
No
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Storage space
15 cubic feet
Mounting hardware requirement
All racks and rails + no rails
Lock included
No
5 out of 5 stars (5 / 5)
Storage space
15 cubic feet
Mounting hardware requirement
All racks and rails + no rails
Lock included
No
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Storage space
15 cubic feet
Mounting hardware requirement
All racks and rails + no rails
Lock included
Yes, TSA Approved lock included
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Storage space
14.6 cubic feet
Mounting hardware requirement
All racks and rails + no rails
Lock included
No
4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)

Top 5 Best Soft Car Top Carriers In 2021 Reviews

1 Keeper 07203-1

This carrier with 15 cubic feet of storage space is made up of sturdy material. Rubber-laminated Nylon construction imparts strength to the overall structure. Resistance to ripping makes the carrier even better for the job. The best thing about this carrier is that it will fit all roof racks.

As far as four-sided roof racks go, they give the perfect support to this carrier. But you don’t need to worry if your car has a two-sided rack. The carrier will fit on it too but would need cautious installation.

Not only is the carrier universal in terms of compatible racks, but it also can fit any type of object shape. Its soft sides can flex to fit odd-shaped goods quite easily without damaging them. With 15 cubic feet of space, you can store quite some load in it.

Moreover, the waterproofing of the carrier bag protects your luggage against water, grit, sand, dust, and sun. Hence, you can easily use it, irrespective of the weather conditions. When it comes to packing and storage, the carrier can fold into a small compact shape. After this, you can conveniently place it in the car boot or in the back seats.

When driving with this bag on your car roof, you will hear no noise. The material does not create noise against the wind and gives a seamless experience to the user. It is a great option for storage expansion for standard vehicles and small SUVs.

Keeper 07203-1
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Heavy-duty rubber laminated nylon construction.
  • Waterproof material keeps the cargo safe against all weather conditions.
  • Provides 15 cubic feet of space.
  • Easy to fold into a small compact shape for storage.
  • It can fit all rooftop racks.

Cons

  • It might start to wear and tear after a few thousand miles.
  • The bag is secured with two small zippers and a small lock, which is not the most efficient security for a cargo bag.

2 RoofBag Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag

RoofBag has compromised neither on quality nor on functionality in this carrier. This is why this product is also one of the most popular among users. It, too, has a 15 cubic feet space that can fit oddly structured objects. But when it comes to installation, you can mount it with any rack or even without a rack. This feature lends it quite an edge in usability. Those who do not want to invest in a carrier or do not want the added weight of it will find this carrier bag exceptionally useful.

Inside the kit, you will find the bag and a couple of strong straps with genuine YKK buckles. These straps properly secure the bag to the car. The YKK buckles, known for their strength and secure hold, ensure that the bag does not disengage from the assembly even at high speed.

Made with heavy-duty polyester and liquid-coated with vinyl, the bag features a triple seal technology. This makes it not only much more resistant to tearing and cutting but also protects the luggage from extreme weather conditions. All in all, this is the best soft car top carrier for heavy luggage.

It has a carrying capacity of 3000lbs that is enough to hold a lot of your cargo. Hence, it becomes perfect for outdoor adventure travel like camping or for long-distance trips. To install it without a rack or side rails, you need to close the door over the strap to hold it.

Unlike cheaper alternatives, the straps do not wick the water inside the car. The door closes properly, leaving no space for the entry of water. Such features are a testament to the great design of the product.

RoofBag Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag
Our rating:5 out of 5 stars (5 / 5)

Pros

  • 3000 lbs carrying capacity and 15 cubic feet of storage space.
  • You can install it with any type of rack or side rails as well as without them.
  • Completely waterproof and weather-resistant.
  • Triple-layer technology protects the cargo as you go.
  • Supported by a two-year warranty.

Cons

  • Vinyl coating of straps instead of lamination is not as strong as the latter.
  • Rack-less installation might not give the optimal drag resistance.

3 FIVKLEMNZ Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier

The security of the luggage to be carried is taken very seriously in this soft carrier. FIVKLEMNZ has introduced an eight strap design to mount the carrier on the rooftop. These eight straps hold the carrier very securely on the car and avoid slippage at high speed and on bumpy roads.

But they don’t stop here.

An anti-slip mat which is to be placed under the carrier is also added to the assembly. Hence, this eliminates any chances of slipping and falling off at high speed or on uneven roads. This also protects the car’s surface and paint job from scratches and skid marks. It is a great choice if you are looking for the best car soft carriers without roof racks.

600D Oxford cloth is used to build this product, which has an incredible waterproof surface. A waterproof zipper closes the double flap to hold the luggage inside. All the seams in the bag are heat-welded to make them completely watertight. Hence, no water enters the bag, and you can use it in extreme weather conditions like snow and rain.

Inside the 15 cubic feet storage space, you can store 5-6 suitcases, sleeping bags, tents, and much more. Use it for all sorts of trips whenever you want. In case you have any queries, you can call their 24×7 customer services for all the answers. What makes this deal worth your money is the 30-day money-back guarantee and a year-long warranty.

FIVKLEMNZ Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Made with 600D Oxford fabric with a watertight zipper.
  • It comes with an anti-slip mat to prevent slippage.
  • Eight straps are used to securely mount the bag to the car with or without a rack.
  • Heat-welded, watertight seams eliminate any chance of water entering the bag.
  • 30-day money-back guarantee and 1-year limited warranty for the product.

Cons

  • The doors might leak when the straps are passed through them.
  • The zipper does not support a security lock.

4 RoofPax Car Roof Bag & Rooftop Cargo Carrier

Premium and military-grade material is used to build this one. The material is completely waterproof and is closed via two zippers. A double coating and dual seam technology further ensure that there is no leakage in the bag.

RoofPax keeps its customers’ safety first. It is the only brand that uses patent-registered door hook straps instead of passing the straps through the door. Passing the straps directly could prove to be very dangerous as it restricts the working of the airbags. This makes the RoofPax roof bag carrier the safest soft carrier on the market. Ten elastic Velcro straps and a built-in slip-resistant mat prevent the bag from experiencing extra pressure and ripping.

Whether you take the smooth roads or bumpy off-road tracks, the carrier bag won’t slip off the vehicle. Furthermore, it can protect the luggage from extreme weather and road conditions. From dusty deserts to wet forests, the carrier can conquer all. You can store your luggage or cargo safely on the rooftop and drive in comfort.

A TSA-approved lock is also present in the bag. Unlike many other bags, the RoofPax provides full security for maximum customer satisfaction. Set number code on the lock and put it on the bag without any worries.

RoofPax provides a valuable warranty for this product as well. If for any reason you are not happy with your purchase, you can contact their customer service for a refund or a quick replacement. Moreover, you get a lifetime warranty on buckle breakage and zip tar.

RoofPax Car Roof Bag & Rooftop Cargo Carrier
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros

  • Military-grade fabric material used for construction.
  • Capable of taking all sorts of roads and weather beating without any problems.
  • Includes a TSA-approved lock for maximum security.
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty on buckle and zipper breakage and tear.
  • Secured by multiple Velcro straps and buckles.

Cons

  • The product needs to be registered on the company website to avail warranty. It does not apply through purchase only.
  • The construction material is not coated.

5 SANHIMA Roof Cargo Carrier Bag

Yet another amazing and super performing product, the SANHIMA carrier, is made with 500*500D PVC Tarpaulin UV-coated mesh. The material gives an all-weather performance. It protects your belongings from grit, water, dust, mud, sun, UV rays, grease, etc. Once you have your goods stored securely inside it, you are in for a smooth and comfortable ride. Be it sudden turns, steep ascents, bumpy roads, or quick brakes; the carrier stays glued to the rooftop.

This carrier, too, could be used with or without a rack or rail. Secured with sturdy Velcro straps, the storage can carry differently sized and shaped objects inside it. The soft and moldable corners allow the bag to accommodate oddly structured things as well.

A common cause of concern with carrier bags is the air drag that slows down the car due to their presence. But in this carrier, the layout is designed in a way that gives it an aerodynamic shape. Hence, the car speeds through easily. This also improves the stability of the carrier on the car and lowers the consumption of gas.

An anti-slip mat is also included to prevent the bag from sliding off or damaging the paint job. You can use it equally well on UV, CMB vans, and buses as you would on Sedans and a variety of smaller cars. Hence, it is almost a universal soft car top carrier.

Use it without any worries under all weather conditions and move from place to place in comfort. The SANHIMA roof cargo carrier bag will keep your luggage safe, dust-free, and dry.

SANHIMA Roof Cargo Carrier Bag
Our rating:4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)

Pros

  • 500*500D PVC Tarpaulin UV-coated mesh gives strength and durability to the bag.
  • Uses an anti-slip mat and straps to securely mount on the car.
  • An aerodynamic shape allows the car to glide through the miles.
  • Usable for SUVs, CMB vans, and buses as well.
  • Water and dust-resistant.
  • It also protects against any sand, mud, rays, or grease that might be encountered along the way.

Cons

  • It does not support locking for security.
  • 14.6 cubic feet of space is available, which is lesser compared to the other options with 15 cubic feet of space.

Best Soft Car Top Carriers Buying Guide

We have seen that different carriers support different features. Where these storage bags can be a huge convenience, if not bought with consideration, they can also prove to be quite useless. Here we discuss the prime things that you need to consider before buying a soft carrier for your car roof.

Size

The most important thing to consider is the size your carrier bag should be. The size is dependent on your need and on the size of the car. Bigger vehicles like high-end SUVs and minivans have a bigger roof. Hence, a bigger bag is more suitable for reaching the roof racks or doors for secure mounting.

best soft car top carrier

For smaller cars, the size is even more important. In case you try to fit a big bag on a small roof, it would keep hanging off the sides. Apart from the roof size, you also need to consider the size and weight of your own luggage. The carrier you buy must be able to snuggly yet comfortably hold all things in place.

Material

Another very important consideration is the material of your carrier bag. Always make sure that the material is waterproof. This way, you can use the carrier in rain, hailstorm, and snow as well. It is even better if the bag is all-weather-resistant and provides protective coverage against sun, dust, mud, etc.

The material should also be sturdy enough to hold everything in without tearing. Even when high wind hits it during high-speed driving, the material of the bag should neither tear nor rip.

Mounting Style

Different carriers need different supports for roof installment. Some require four-sided roof racks while others suffice with two-sided racks. Side rails are another popular way to tie the straps of the carrier.

However, now carriers that can be installed without racks or rails are quite common. They provide flexibility in use and can mount easily to any car. As long as the car has doors, these carriers will fit. Hence, you must make sure that your carrier complies with the hardware in your car.

Security

Since carrier bags are mounted on the outside of the vehicle, the chances of theft are ever-present. Strong zippers and straps must be present on the carrier of your choice to securely close it and keep your stuff from other people’s reach.

If the zippers are big enough to support a padlock or if the bag comes with a lock itself, then that is even better. Make sure that neither is your carrier easy to open, nor is the zipper too weak to be easily broken off.

Benefits of Soft Car Top Carriers

Soft car top carriers have quite a few benefits. The usability of these is enough to convince you of their importance. They can truly bring great comfort and ease to your driving and traveling.

  • Extra space makes for a spacious ride

Often, for a long trip or for an off-road outdoor adventure, you need more luggage. It needs to be carried from place to place, and your car’s boot might not be enough for it. In such cases, you can resort to storing your stuff on the back seat of the car, but that makes the ride for passengers extremely uncomfortable.

soft car top carrier

But soft car top carriers bring a much-needed solution to this problem. When these are installed on your roof, you can fill them up with your suitcases, boxes, tents, etc. This way, you can strap your luggage safely and ride in comfort as well.

  • Protection

Many people also use open-surface carriers. But the advantage that soft carriers have over open-surface carriers is that the former closes and covers all the cargo inside it. This way, it keeps your belongings safe from the beatings of the road and the harshness of the weather. Waterproof and weather-resistant carriers can provide protection against the sun, snow, rain, mud, sand, dust, etc. Hence, the usability expands to different road types, terrains, and climatic conditions.

  • Lighter in weight

Compared with hard car top carriers, soft ones are lighter in weight. As a result, apart from the luggage, there is no extra burden on the car. Lesser weight means lesser drag experienced by the car and lesser fuel consumed.

Moreover, the soft carriers have corners and edges that aren’t rigid and can easily house oddly shaped objects. Altogether, they are much more efficient both in terms of use and compatibility with the vehicle.

Types of Carriers

Generally, there exist two types of car top carriers: hardtop and soft top carriers. Here we will look into the construction and function of both.

  • Hardtop carriers

As the name suggests, these carriers are made up of hard material and are mounted on top of the car. They are usually made with ABS plastic. The construction is sturdy, strong, and dependable. This purpose of this type of carrier is to maintain its shape and form a box-like structure. The major advantage associated with this is that your cargo remains secure and free from the danger of slipping off and breaking.

soft car top carrier reviews

Moreover, excellent weather protection is also provided by the hard shell. They are a bit heavier when you compare them to soft carriers. Hardtop carriers might be easy or difficult to install, depending on their mounting method. Some need specialized structures for a secure hold while others make use of already-present racks and rails. Between the two, hardshell carriers are more expensive, owing to the protection and usability that they provide.

  • Soft top carriers

We have seen in this article that soft-top carriers are made up of foldable material like leather, fabric, etc. As a result, they are lighter in weight and are capable of holding items with odd shapes and sizes. These carriers are much simpler to install and make use of already existing racks and rails.

The latest models can even mount on a roof without racks and rails. The material is waterproof and weather-resistant, giving usability in wet conditions or dusty terrains. Even though they provide security for your goods, they usually lack locks and are easier to break into compared to hardtop carriers. Their soft shells are cheaper to produce and hence cost less compared to hardtop carriers.

Top Brands

It often proves very helpful when you know what brands are reliable and will cater to your needs when buying a product. This stands true for car top carriers as well. Therefore, we, too, will look into the top brands that offer some amazing products.

soft car top carrier guide

RoofBag

You know that the brand knows its market when it is widely popular throughout the States. Such is the case with RoofBag. They are a brand with popularity expanding far and beyond. They specialize entirely in rooftop carriers and have released some of the best carriers available.

With waterproofing available in all soft top carriers, you can find sizes suiting your need. Not only that, but their products are quite easy to install and use as well. Hence, if you are looking for a top brand that delivers both quality and performance, then this is your go-to brand.

soft car top carriers guide

Keeper

Dealing in auto parts, hardware, and carriers, Keeper is yet another great brand. It knows vehicle accessories and car parts like no other. You can easily find winches, tie-down, hooks, bungees, and many other products here.

When it comes to top carriers, their experience in automotive accessories and parts shines through. The result is unique products that are full of features fit to tackle all sorts of road and weather conditions. Keeper products truly are a keeper.

soft car top carrier review

RoofPax

“Travel more, worry less” is the mantra that RoofPax goes by and also lives up to it. They really do provide their customers with a worry-less travel experience. You can find the ultimate performance and supreme quality recovery and towing equipment, as well as some amazing tie-down equipment.

And as expected, when it comes to carriers, the brand does not disappoint. RoofPax introduces very useful features in all its top carriers that enhance its usability and ensure its long-lasting performance.

Soft Car Top Carriers Pricing

The prices of soft car top carriers vary from unit to unit and brand to brand. The difference is primarily due to the size, material used, and flexibility in mounting methods.

Thick material with foolproof water-resistant and weather-resistant qualities will cost more than a thin single-layer waterproof carrier. Similarly, larger sizes cost more, and the ability to mount on to any car irrespective of the availability of racks and rails further raises the value of a carrier. The prices can start from around $45.00 and go up to $120.00. However, you can find a fairly decent model with a mid-range price.

Conclusion

With the growing need for space, we also need more storage inside our cars. For this, soft car top carriers provide a very good solution. They are easy to install, waterproof, and weather-resistant, as well as capable of harboring differently shaped and sized objects.

From the above-discussed options, we believe that the RoofBag Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag takes the crown. It has all the features of a good carrier like weather resistance, multiple mounting options, and versatility in vehicle compatibility, etc. Also, a two-year limited warranty backs it. When put together, all these features make for a very useful deal.

Leave a Comment